Non-Epileptic events (including Non-Epileptic Seizures / Stress seizures)

What are Non-Epileptic Seizures / Non-Epileptic Events?

Non-Epileptic Events are seizure-like events that are not caused by Epilepsy.

Epileptic seizures are electrical storms in the brain. In contrast, there is no electrical storm in the brain during a Non-Epileptic Event.

Epileptic seizures are caused by a ELECTRICAL storm inside the brain. During Non-epileptic events, there is NO electrical storm.

What causes Non-Epileptic Events?

There are many causes of Non-Epileptic Seizures. Here is a list of the most important causes:

  • Sleep disorders such as REM behavior disorder, Nightmares & Narcolepsy.
  • Cardiac rhythm problems which cause sudden unconsciousness
  • Seizures caused by stress. These are also called Psychogenic seizures or Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES)

The attacks caused by these disorders can look like Epileptic Seizures. This may lead to a mis-diagnosis of Epilepsy.

Episodes of unconciousness produced by cardiac arryhthmia may look like seizures.

In many cases Epilepsy Monitoring Unit (EMU) evaluation may be needed (see below). EMU evaluation is also called long term video-EEG (ltm-vEEG) evaluation.

What are Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES)?

PNES are a special type of Non-Epileptic Event. They are produced by psychological stress or worry.

These are real attacks that can be very frightening.

Stress may produce seizure-like attacks.

Earlier, these used to be called “Pseudo-Seizures”, but this term is no longer used. Some doctors use the term “Non-Epileptic Seizures (NES)” instead of “Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES)”.

PNES is used more commonly. In practice, I myself prefer to use the term NES instead of PNES.

It is possible to identify the exact mental stress causing this problem. Sometimes, the source of stress may be hidden deep within our mind.

Can you explain the rest of the words in “PNES”?


  • Psychogenic = From the Mind (Epileptic seizures arise from the brain)
  • Non-Epileptic = Not caused due to Epilepsy
  • Seizures = These events look like seizures.

So, this is a disease with repeated “Seizure-like-attacks arising from the Mind”.

Ah okay! So this is not a “real” disease like Epilepsy?

Nothing could be further from the truth!

PNES is a very real problem for those who suffer from it.

Depression and anxiety are very real problems, that need professional treatment.

While we know a bit about the brain, we know very little about the Mind. We don’t completely understand how the mind affects the body, but we know that it does.

People who have a lot of stress, for example, are very likely to have higher blood pressures and early heart attacks. Would you ever walk up to a person who was having a heart attack due to high stress, and tell him he/she didn’t have a real problem? You wouldn’t – It would be quite unintelligent to do so.

PNES is a similarly serious problem, except we don’t understand it as well as we know a heart-attack. This lack of understanding reflects a shortcoming of medical knowledge, rather than of the patient.

We don’t understand PNES completely.

What causes Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES)?

As noted earlier, Non-Epileptic Seizures (NES) are caused by psychological stress.

These are real events which need to be understood properly.

Some people’s minds are very sensitive to stress. Small incidents, such as arguments, may overload their brain with stress.

Every time their mind becomes overloaded with stress, it stops functioning normally. Their mind may behave in abnormal ways – for example, they may have a sudden explosion of panic.

That is when you get a Non-Epileptic Seizure.

Depression can be tough to break out of, but it is doable.

Once Non-Epileptic seizures begin they may cause even more stress/worry. This increased stress can cause more Non-Epileptic Seizures.

This is called a vicious cycle. Increased stress causes more Non-Epileptic Seizures, which in turn causes more stress.

This vicious cycle needs to be broken.

Can PNES & Epilepsy occur in the same person?


This is a crucial point to remember – The same person may have both Epileptic & Non-Epileptic attacks. Some researchers have estimated that up to 25-50% of patients with Epilepsy also have PNES attacks.

Some patients may have both Epileptic seizures and Non-Epileptic attacks.

Therefore, even if you have PNES, it is absolutely essential to make sure that you don’t have Epilepsy as well.

Many researchers have highlighted this point. In 2013, the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) proposed a set of minimum requirements for a diagnosis of PNES:

[visual-link-preview encoded=”eyJ0eXBlIjoiZXh0ZXJuYWwiLCJwb3N0IjowLCJwb3N0X2xhYmVsIjoiIiwidXJsIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly9vbmxpbmVsaWJyYXJ5LndpbGV5LmNvbS9kb2kvZnVsbC8xMC4xMTExL2VwaS4xMjM1NiIsImltYWdlX2lkIjoxMjgwNywiaW1hZ2VfdXJsIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly9lcGlsZXBzeXBhcmtpbnNvbnMuaW4vd3AtY29udGVudC91cGxvYWRzLzIwMjAvMDQvZXBpLjIwMTMuNTQuaXNzdWUtMTEuY292ZXJfLmpwZyIsInRpdGxlIjoiSUxBRTogTWluaW11bSByZXF1aXJlbWVudHMgZm9yIHRoZSBkaWFnbm9zaXMgb2YgcHN5Y2hvZ2VuaWMgbm9uZXBpbGVwdGljIHNlaXp1cmVzIiwic3VtbWFyeSI6IiIsInRlbXBsYXRlIjoidXNlX2RlZmF1bHRfZnJvbV9zZXR0aW5ncyJ9″]

Thus, a person who has both Epileptic Seizures & PNES may be labelled as having “only PNES” instead.

Evaluation of Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES)

Unfortunately, we have no instrument that can measure psychological stress. We therefore need to rule out other problems, before concluding that a person has PNES only.

To complicate things, many people with Epileptic seizures have tremendous mental stress. And some patients have both Epileptic and Psychogenic Non-Epileptic seizures.

So, how do we diagnose Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES)?

Sometimes, doctors can make educated guesses. The movements during stress-seizures (Non-Epileptic) are slightly different, than those due to electrical storms (Epileptic). PNES can be longer than Epileptic seizures. The patient may be able to respond partially during PNES. And so on…

Most patients who have seizures also get an MRI and a routine (1-2 hour long) EEG. The MRI and EEG may be if the patient has Epileptic seizures, or both kind of seizures. They are normal if a patient has only PNES.

An EEG records electrical activity in the brain.

These criteria don’t always work.

If after all these things, the cause of seizures is still not clear, the doctor may advise EMU evaluation.

EMU (Epilepsy Monitoring Unit) evaluation:

EMU evaluation is also called long term Video-EEG (ltm-vEEG) evaluation.

The patient is admitted to the hospital in a comfortable room. He is attached to the EEG machine. In addition, other machines measure his heart rate, blood oxygen level, and ECG at all times.

Epilepsy Monitoring Unit
A typical Epilepsy Monitoring Unit (EMU) room

The goal is to “capture” a seizure.

  • If during the seizure, there is an electrical storm in the brain – the person has Epilepsy.
  • If there is no electrical storm – the patient has Non-Epileptic Events.

This determination is quite definite. Therefore, EMU evaluation is called the “gold standard” for evaluation of psychogenic Non-Epileptic seizures (PNES).

Treatment of Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES)

Traditional medications given for Epileptic Seizures (Anti-Epileptics) are not effective against PNES.

This is expected. These medications prevent Electrical storms in the brain. PNES is not caused by Electrical storms. PNES are caused by mental stress.

Treatment of PNES is possible. Improvement is possible. Many people stop having PNES entirely after proper treatment.

Treatment of PNES is a multi-step process. It is best coordinated by a mental health professional such as a psychiatrist or counsellor. This process requires both the doctor and patient to work hard and be patient.

Steps in treatment of Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES)

Step 1:

The first step is to find the exact reason for mental stress.

Sometimes, this reason may be hidden deep within our mind.

Our mind unconsciously suppresses unpleasant memories. These memories may be bad events from our childhood, or even recent events such as loss of a job, or the death of a loved one.

The source of stress may be an incident that happened very long ago.

Step 2:

The second step is to find ways to reduce this stress. These methods may include:

  • Confronting the source of stress directly (e.g. prolonged exposure therapy)
  • Family therapy / Couples counselling
  • Learning alternative methods of thinking about the source of stress (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy – CBT)
Couneslling helps to reduce stress.

Step 3:

Sometimes, the source of stress cannot be found.

In these cases, general measures to reduce the stress are useful. They may include:

  • Progressive relaxation techniques
  • Breathing exercises
  • Meditation
  • Group therapy
Group therapy has been shown to be effective for PNES.

Prognosis of Psychogenic Non-Epileptic seizures (PNES) – Do they stop?


PNES can stop after treatment.

PNES usually do not case bodily injury. However, they are a real condition. They are produced by severe mental stress.

PNES frequency deceases after the above-mentioned measures. Many times, PNES stops completely.

There are 2 things to remember:

  1. Better results are obtained by early treatment. If there is a delay of more than 12 months in starting proper treatment, improvement can be delayed. Unfortunately, even in developed countries, this delay can be up to 5 years [Kanemoto 2017].
    Often this delay is caused by delayed referral for EMU (Epilepsy Monitoring Unit) evaluation [Kerr 2021]. If your seizures are uncontrolled, you should request your doctor to refer you to a EMU.
  2. Treatment of PNES requires you to have an accepting, open attitude. For this reason perhaps, treatment is even more effective in children. [Chinta 2008].
Early treatment has a greater chance of controlling PNES.


Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES) Summary

A recently published paper [Pohlmann-Eden 2019] has a nice summary figure.

Click on the image below to read the larger version.

screenshot 20210428 095446 2





Caution: This information is not a substitute for professional care. Do not change your medications/treatment without your doctor's permission.
Dr. Siddharth Kharkar

Dr. Siddharth Kharkar

Dr. Siddharth Kharkar has been recognized as one of the best neurologists in Mumbai by Outlook India magazine and India today Magazine. He is a board certified (American Board of Psychiatry & Neurology certified) Neurologist.

Dr. Siddharth Kharkar is a Epilepsy specialist in Mumbai & Parkinson's specialist in Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.

He has trained in the best institutions in India, US and UK including KEM hospital in Mumbai, Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, University of California at San Francisco (UCSF), USA & Kings College in London.

Call 022-4897-1800

Send Message

NeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson's Clinic - Dr. Kharkar IconNeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson's Clinic - Dr. Kharkar

near LIC, Dr Balabhai Nanavati hospital, near LIC, Swami Vivekananda Road, LIC Colony, Vile Parle

4.5 78 reviews

  • Avatar Paras Prabhu ★★★★★ 5 months ago
    Out patient is epileptic from about 10 years and her seizure gotten worse during the past year with the frequency of about 3-4 times a week.So we consulted … More Dr. Kharkar. He tried a few medicines, and within 1.5-2 months now the patient is feeling very well now. There are no seizures for 14 days currently.Dr. tried to keep medicines as minimum as possible. He also tried to keep the cost of the treatment minimum.When some of the medicines started showing side-effects, he was quick to switch the medicines to the better options.Overall I think we are getting a best of the available treatments. We thank you very much Dr. Kharkar.
  • Avatar Sanjay Pradhan ★★★★★ 5 months ago
    Dr. Kharkar is truly exceptional. He is extremely knowledgeable. But simultaneously, he is extremely patient and kind - taking the time and care to respond … More to all the questions. It is rare to come across a doctor who is not in a hurry to get on to the next patient, but instead, focuses on the one in front with full attention, expertise and compassion. A great experience.
  • Avatar Manish Ranjan ★★★★★ 6 months ago
    I have been visiting Dr Kharkar for treatment of my father. He is a very friendly doctor. He listens to our concerns with lot of patience. He also explains … More the issue in much greater details. He has really been of great help. My father is much better now.
  • Avatar N N ★★★★★ 5 months ago
    We visited Dr. Kharkhar for treatment regarding my mum - who is a multi-stroke patient and has aphasia. Certain medications were creating complications … More with her condition and Dr. Kharkhar was able to help mitigate the issue. We found him and his approach to be incredibly compassionate, considerate, individualized and patient-friendly. He advice is astute, up-to-date and empathetic. His treatment always comes from a deeply human place and is about seeing how to help the patient and their caregivers feel more at ease. Something that is quite rare and refreshing within the medical community.We feel that he genuinely cares about the patients that he is treating and is always kind and respectful in his communication. Moreover, his admin team is very efficient and prompt and it's a pleasure to deal with them.Would highly recommend Dr Kharkhar himself - though we must say our experience with Nanavati hospital itself has been less than ideal.Hope this helps.
  • Avatar Vineet Badhwar ★★★★ 3 months ago
    One of the best doctors in Mumbai,listen to patients with concern very helpful, takes advise of other doctors very seriously. Examines the disease very … More carefully and advises patient of the medicine accordingly . Over all a good human being.
  • Avatar aman ul hauq Khan ★★★★ 6 months ago
    Dr Kharkar gives you all the time you need to hear you out in complete detail. He probes in depth to ensure he has managed to gain all data points to find … More the best way forward medically for you. He is an authority on the subject. After 4 years of suffering I have found my go to doctor
  • Avatar Pinakin Shah ★★★★★ 4 months ago
    One of the best Dr. Gives complete attention and time to listen to patient's history, issues. Explains various options of treatment with pros and … More cons.
  • Avatar Lawrence Castellino ★★★★★ 6 months ago
    Exceptional experience with an expert,Dr. Kharkar is a knowledge house. It is rare nowadays to find doctors with patience, knowledge, and a flair for … More handling patient’s questions, besides Dr. Kharkar’s bedside manners are exemplary. I am privileged to be treated by such an amazing soul. I have told him and will repeat it here that “I am advancing my move back to India although I am a US Citizen, because I know I am in good hands and will be well taken care of. Thanks Dr. Kharkar for your selfless service!
  • Avatar Hemant Kansara ★★★★★ 8 months ago
    Great doctor!! Really appreciate.The doctor diagnosed to my sister correctly and start treatment, she has good improvement after taking medicine prescribed … More by doctor as no epilepsy attake. We have good experience with the doctor. Thank you
  • Avatar Anil Chinchulkar ★★★★★ 8 months ago
    We have visited the hospital and meet the Dr. S. Kharkar. And my personal experience is very much better and exilent. My father is very well recover as … More we thought. Thanks to Nanavati Hospital and Dr. S. Kharkar.
  • Avatar MAMTA YADAV ★★★★★ 8 months ago
    The services that I received from doctor Siddharth kharkar is excellent ,and the other doctor is also very good who had taken initial discussion with me … More ...and the staff are friendly and ensure that I am properly informed about my health and care and would highly recommend to anyone..
  • Avatar Khushi Valia ★★★★★ 8 months ago
    Had very Severe migraine attacks for years and suddenly my migraine had triggered for continuous 5 days thats when I contact Dr Siddharth and was fortunate … More to have a effective medication which help me reduced my triggers and headaches..Lucky in few months I have very less days of headache in a month and can do my Daily life with much ease.
  • Avatar JAIKUMAR MANI ★★★★★ a year ago
    My experience with Dr Siddharth Kharkar was really awesome. It’s always great to be in the presence of someone who is a renowned expert in his field & … More it brings peace of mind that the advice will obviously be the correct one. In addition, his ability to convey complex workings of the human brain in such simple terms that a layman like me could easily understand was something I really appreciated. I heartily Thank Dr Kharkar for his astute advice & gladly recommend him to anyone who needs a neurologist.
  • Avatar Rohit shetye ★★★★★ a year ago
    Best Dr. we have ever meet. Dr. Listened to us patiently and gave us the proper solution. No unnecessary test or didn’t frighten us. Thank you so much … More Dr.
  • Avatar Ashish Patil ★★★★★ a year ago
    Great doctor!! Really appreciate.The doctor diagnosed me correctly and start treatment that will help me a lots to improve my condition. The doctor is … More really good, calm and his nature is down to earth, gives confidence to patient!!! Thank you!!!
  • Avatar Bianca D'silva ★★★★★ a year ago
    We had been looking for a specialist in parkinsons for a while now, for my father and when we found Dr. Siddharth Kharka's details on Google, we were … More partly relieved. Partly because, we were all very anxious not knowing how would our visit turn out. I appreciate Dr. Kharkar and his team. He was very clear in his explanations, his knowledge about parkinsons. He took the time to answer the questions we had, went over the diagnosis and started necessary treatment immediately. The only drawback we experienced was the waiting time. Overall, we left the clinic satisfied, knowing much more than when we walked in. We would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a specialist.
  • Avatar Neelam Satghare ★★★★★ a year ago
    I have visited the doctor clinic for the first timeBut he gave good advice and helped me overcomeMy doubts and queries. It was a good experience.I am very … More thankful for cooperation.
  • Avatar Nitin Ghotge ★★★★★ a year ago
    Dr.Sidharth Kharkar is one of the best neurologist i came across ....He is really genuine and focused .....We really satisfied after consultancy...
  • Avatar Krishna kumari Radhakrishnan ★★★★★ a year ago
    Hi Sharing my experience with Dr KharkarI had consulted with dr regarding my husband’sProblems of tremors. Dr immediately diagnosed on video consultation … More and could help him to control the tremors s of Parkinson’s disease.I found him genuinely polite and free to talk n patiently listening to the patients problem.Now my husband regained his balance n tremors controlled. Many many thanks to Dr Kharkar
  • Avatar a kumar ★★★★★ a year ago
    Dr kharkar is very nice doctor, sir explained each and every thing very nicely, and i am thankful for Dr kharkar for his treatment .
  • Avatar Nidhi Sonawane ★★★★★ a year ago
    I had a positive experience with the doctor. He was very sympathetic. His communication skills were good and listened with patience.
  • Avatar Ujwala Sawant ★★★★★ a year ago
    Because of Dr.kharkar sir my husband got new life. Tnx sir.
  • Avatar Mythili Balasubramanian ★★★★★ a year ago
    Consultation with the doctor was a very satisfying experience. Was empathetic in his approach, and responded positively to all the queries we had. Thank … More you doctor!
  • Avatar Govind Patel ★★★★★ a year ago
    Doctor explained very Good nice person give length time to check body
  • Avatar Sharmila Kumawat ★★★★★ a year ago
    Dr Siddharth is one of the best Dr I have ever met. He is kind, polite, helpful and very selfless person. I have migraine and I am his patient since more … More than 2 years. The staff is always helpful and Dr Siddharth is just beyond words for me. Thank you for ur selfless service and kindness u give to all ur patients.

Leave a Comment

India Today Magazine - 2021Noted as one of the Best Neurologists in Mumbai