Dr. Siddharth Kharkar

Dr. Siddharth Kharkar is a globally trained neurologist in Mumbai, specializing in Epilepsy and Parkinson’s Disease. With expertise from top institutes like Johns Hopkins and UCSF, he delivers precise diagnoses, advanced treatments like DBS and Video EEG, and personalized care focused on long-term results and quicker recovery.

Seizures: Always prevent seizures during pregnancy! Can Epilepsy Patient Get Pregnant – drkharkar

This is an article from the Safe Pregnancy in Epilepsy patient guide. Women with Epilepsy can have seizures during pregnancy. Having seizures while pregnant can hurt the baby & mother. It is incorrect to say that pregnancy triggers seizures. But seizures can increase due to 5 important causes of seizures in pregnancy. It is imporant to know these causes of seizures in pregnancy. Taking simple precautions can prevent seizures while pregnant. Table of Contents Can I have seizures during pregnancy? Yes. For example: 1/3rd of women with Epilepsy who get pregnant have breakthrough seizures. This data comes from a research group from Europe. They studied 3500 pregnancies. Can pregnancy trigger seizures? The same European study found two other things: They found that 15% of women had worsening of seizures during pregnancy. Surprisingly, 12% of women have decreased seizures during pregnancy. So, it is too simplistic to say that pregnancy can trigger seizures in patients with Epilepsy. If that were the case, none of the women would have decreased seizures during pregnancy. Why do some women have decreased seizures while pregnant? Epilepsy is not a static condition. It’s intensity waxes and wanes, like the waves in the ocean. You may have noticed this if you have uncontrolled epilepsy. On some months, you get more seizures but cannot pinpoint why. On other months, you stop getting seizures and you don’t know why. Some researchers strongly believe that this is the cause. That increased seizures during pregnancy are just caused by the waxing & waning nature of Epilepsy. But this is not the complete story. Based on research, and in my experience – there are 5 important causes of seizures in pregnancy. To prevent seizures during pregnancy, you need to pay heed to these… 5 causes of seizures in pregnancy: Of these 5 causes of seizures in pregnancy, 4 are more common in Epilepsy patients. The last is equally common in women with epilepsy, and those without epilepsy. (1) Uncontrolled Epilepsy before getting pregnant This one is obvious. Of all the causes of seizures in pregnancy, this is the best predictor of seizures. In some people, Epilepsy is difficult to control. If you were having breakthrough seizures even before getting pregnant, you could have seizures while pregnant. For example: A study in Australia studied almost 1000 pregnancies. Women who were seizure free for at least one year were 4 times less likely to have seizures during pregnancy. Here are the exact chances per that study: If you are seizure-free for 1 year, less than 20% chance of having seizures during pregnancy. If you are not seizure-free, 75% chance that you will have seizures during pregnancy. Another study done in the US (the MONEAD study), had similar findings. So, to prevent seizures during pregnancy – make sure you are seizure-free for at least 1 year before getting pregnant. (2) Stopping seizure medications Some women stop seizure medications when they realize they are pregnant. They are trying to prevent harm to the baby (Teratogenicity). This is a bad choice. This is a easily preventable cause of seizures in pregnancy. Having seizures while pregnant can be dangerous for you and your baby. Please don’t stop seizure medications by yourself, ever. You can and should talk to your doctor about all options. He/she will most likely advise you not to stop medications. In most cases, it is just too risky. Taking your medications regularly is critical to prevent seizures during pregnancy. (3) Changing seizure medications after becoming pregnant Some seizure medications are more likely to harm the baby. Other seizure medications are safer for the baby. You can consider switching the safer medications before pregnancy. What about after you get pregnant? Would taking the safer medications instead be better? This seems more reasonable than stopping seizure medications entirely. Perhaps it is. But: Usually, this too is not a good choice. This, too, is an easily preventable cause of seizures in prengnacy. The 1998 American Academy of Neurology guidelines advise against this. They also superbly explain why: You could have uncontrolled seizures. If you change medications, the baby is exposed to two different medications. This ,may be more dangerous than any one medication. Patients go to a neurologist several weeks after becoming pregnant. By that time, there is limited advantage to change. (4) Decreased levels of seizure medications during pregnancy Many of the causes of seizures in pregnancy discussed so far are obvious. But many patients and caregivers are not aware of decreased levels of seizure medications. During pregnancy, the liver and kidney go into over-drive. The liver inactivates medications more quickly. The kidneys throw medications out of the body more quickly than usual. Also during pregnancy, the volume of your blood increases. The medications you are taking get diluted. Thus, the concentration of seizure medications decreases. There are other ways in which the levels of seizure medications can decrease. These include frequent vomiting, decreased absorption, decreased binding to proteins in the blood etc… Ultimately, your brain gets less seizure medication. This can lead to breakthrough seizures. To prevent seizures during pregnancy, it is critical to ensure adequate blood levels. This may mean that you need to increase the dose of epilepsy medications. Which seizure medications are affected? Almost all seizure medication levels decrease in pregnancy. But some seizure medications are more severely affected. The table below shows data from a recent paper (Arfman 2020). Marked drop in levels Lamotrigine (50%) Levetiracetam (50%) Oxcarbazepine Phenyotin* Valproate* Topiramate* Marked drop in levels Carbamazepine Unknown Lacosamide Clobazam Gabapentin Perampanel *Phenytoin, Valproate & Topiramate should be avoided in pregnancy anyway, due to the risk of teratogenicity. Prevent seizures during pregnancy due to reduced levels: First of course, you should aim for good seizure control before becoming pregnant. Then, before getting pregnant, your doctor will check a blood level. This is the “baseline blood level”. This is the level at which your brain is happy, at which it stops having seizures. Some people suggest doing this twice before pregnancy to get the best possible estimate. During pregnancy, your doctor may regularly check

Seizures: Always prevent seizures during pregnancy! Can Epilepsy Patient Get Pregnant – drkharkar Read More »

Deep Brain Stimulation Cost in India [Reduce DBS cost!] – DBS Surgery in India – Drkharkar

Deep Brain Stimulation cost in India varies between Rs.12 lakh to Rs. 16 lakh. Most of the cost variation is based on the DBS device used. A rough breakup of the minimum cost is as follows: Expense Approximate cost (INR) Approximate cost (USD) Pre-operative evaluation Rs. 50,000 $ 680 DBS Device (Activa-PC) Rs. 7.6 lakh $ 10166 Operation charges (Hospital) Rs. 1 lakh $ 1337 Doctor’s charges (Neurologist, Neurosurgeon etc) Rs. 1.5 lakh $ 2006 Hospital stay including medications Rs. 1.5 lakh $ 2006 TOTAL (Minimum cost of DBS in India – For example, at Nanavati Hospital) Rs. 12.1 lakh $ 16,195 On the whole, this is the minimum DBS cost in India, or rather the DBS cost in Mumbai. This is the typical DBS cost for Parkinson’s in Mumbai, when my team at Nanavati hospital, Mumbai treats a patient with DBS. This cost of Deep Brain Stimulation in India may vary with time and location. It is very reasonable to get a firm, clear estimate from the hospital before making a decision. You should know a few critical things: Table Of Contents DBS cost in Charitable/Governmental Indian institutes DBS cost with non-US DBS devices If the cost is lower, is DBS surgery in India inferior to USA/UK/Europe? Why do some DBS surgeries cost up to Rs. 16 lakh or even more? Are there any other ways to reduce DBS cost in India? In summary Dr. Siddharth Kharkar NeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson’s Clinic – Dr. Kharkar DBS cost in Charitable/Governmental Indian institutes Some semi-charitable hospitals in India also perform this procedure. For example, the Nizam’s institute of medical sciences in Hyderabad performs a large number of DBS surgeries. Another option is the Sree Chitra Insitute in Thiruvantapuram, Kerala. A third option is AIIMS, in New Delhi. The All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) is one of the Governmental organizations providing phenomenal services to Indians, including DBS. The DBS cost at these Governmental institutions may be even lower. They may also be able to acquire the DBS device at lower cost from the companies. But logistically, getting a DBS at charitable institutes in India may be a bit difficult. These institutes deliver really admirable, yeoman service with excellent outcomes to a very large number of people. For example, the wait periods for getting DBS are frequently very long, sometimes many years. Scheduling appointments may be difficult. If you are particular about convenience, timings, accessibility, personalized attention & counselling etc you may want to follow-up at a private hospital instead. DBS cost with non-US DBS devices Two manufacturers in China have now started manufacturing DBS devices. Here are the links to the 2 Chinese companies manufacturing DBS: PINS Medical SceneRay Medical  Two chinese companies have started producing DBS devices. These are cheaper, but less well-proven as compared to the US devices. Just to remind you, there are 3 US manufacturers of DBS devices. You can read all about the American DBS devices by reading this article on my website. Here are the links to the company websites. Medronic ‘s Activa System Abbot’s Vercise System St. Jude’s Inifinity system. The cost of Chinese DBS devices is expected to be much lower than the US-made devices. There are three issues to consider: These devices have not been specifically approved by the Indian FDA yet. The effectiveness of these devices is not as well established as US devices. The very long term reliability of the hardware is not known. Long term service (e.g. battery replacements & availability of DBS programming devices) is a concern. This is a developing situation. China makes reliable cell phones and other electronic devices. However, their expertise in manufacturing medical electronics is not as established as the US. At this point, this appears to be an unreliable option to reduce DBS cost in India. But as more information becomes available, this might be one avenue through which Deep Brain Stimulation Cost in India may be reduced. If the cost is lower, is DBS surgery in India inferior to USA/UK/Europe? No. India is one of the best countries in the world to get tertiary level care. The level of care given by my team at Nanavati hospital, Mumbai is excellent & comparable to any other hospital in World. Almost all members of our team at Nanavati hospital, Mumbai – including myself – are internationally trained. Surgeon experience: Having worked in many systems throughout the world, I can confidently state that the expertise of Neurosurgeons in India is second to none. The stereotactic procedure used to insert the wire into a precise position may seem like magic. Thankfully, it is used in many other brain procedures, particularly brain biopsy. As a result, many neurosurgeons in India have excellent results with the procedure. Surgical Equipment: At this time, much of the neurosurgical equipment is imported. For example: The Frame used to guide wire insertion is imported from the USA or Europe. Many places use the Leksell system from Sweden, which is one of the most popular systems internationally. The MRI and CT machines are usually from one of 3 manufacturers – Philips, Seimens or GE (USA). Much of the surgical equipment used for DBS in India is imported from the US / Europe.DBS devices used in India Lastly, regarding the DBS devices, the US devices are marketed by the same companies in India, who also provide the after-surgery services.  Amongst all DBS systems, the price of Medtronic’s Activa system is the lowest in India. Therefore, it is the most commonly used DBS device in this country. Why do some DBS surgeries cost up to Rs. 16 lakh or even more? The higher cost of surgery is mainly based on the type of DBS device used. Should you select a more expensive device? The DBS devices which are rechargeable are costlier than the non-rechargeable devices. They last longer. So, battery changes are not required often. The newer devices from Abbot (Vercise) and St. Jude (Infinity) offer technologically advanced features like current steering. But they are also very expensive. Here is a video describing what the newer, more expensive devices can do: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nVLWauTKfPo You can read more about DBS device

Deep Brain Stimulation Cost in India [Reduce DBS cost!] – DBS Surgery in India – Drkharkar Read More »

Fertility: Can a man or woman with epilepsy have a baby?

This is an article from the Safe Pregnancy in Epilepsy patient guide. Epilepsy does not decrease fertility. But Epilepsy medications can affect fertility. Epilepsy medications can affect the reproductive system in women. Some medications like valproate can cause PCOD.  Epilepsy medications can cause temporary problems in getting pregnant. Some epilepsy medications can decrease sperm counts. However, epilepsy medications usually do not decrease fertility of males. Hello! I am Dr Siddharth Kharkar, a Neurologist in Thane, India and a Neurologist in Mumbai, India. I provide Parkinson’s treatment in India and am an Epilepsy specialist in India. I provide Epilepsy surgery in India at Mumbai & Parkinson’s surgery in India. Come, let’s learn about this important topic. I think knowing the facts will relieve your stress! Table of Contents Can a woman with Epilepsy have a baby? Yes! Certainly and definitely! A woman with Epilepsy can get pregnant. A woman with Epilepsy can have a baby. Many women with epilepsy have babies every year. So no, neither epilepsy nor epilepsy medications decrease fertility in women drastically! You need to be well informed about pregnancy in epilepsy. Also, there are some extra things to take care of. These articles cover almost everything you need to know about pregnancy in Epilepsy. Does Epilepsy affect the reproductive system? No. There is some controversy about this topic. But, recent research shows that Epilepsy does not affect fertility. For example:A recent US study looked at women who were trying to get pregnant. They studied both women with epilepsy, and women without epilepsy. Most women became pregnant in less than 1 year. Women with epilepsy were equally likely to become pregnant. So, what is the controversy? Older research shows that Epilepsy patients may have trouble getting pregnant. There is a simple reason for the difference between newer and older studies. Patients in earlier studies were on older medications like Phenobarbital. Older epilepsy medications can decrease fertility (see below). In summary, Epilepsy itself does not affect fertility. But in some cases, older epilepsy medications decrease fertility. Read more below. Do epilepsy medications affect fertility in women? Yes. Some medications can. Please note that these epilepsy medications decrease fertility. They do not abolish it. Many women get pregnant while taking these medications. Epilepsy medications decrease fertility in women in 2 different ways: (1) Valproate: Valproate is one of the older seizure medications. It can disrupt a female’s reproductive cycle. Valproate may cause a condition called Polycystic Ovarian Disease (PCOD). PCOD causes irregular cycles. PCOD can prevent the female’s eggs from developing normally. As a result, patients with PCOD find it more difficult to become pregnant. (2) “Enzyme Inducing seizure medications”: The liver gradually inactivates hormones floating in the blood. This gives the hormones some time to act on various body parts. Some seizure medications are called “Enzyme Inducers“. They can cause your liver to go into overdrive. It starts inactivating hormones rapidly! The hormones include estrogen & progesterone. These sexual hormones are important for becoming pregnant. These “Enzyme Inducing” medications include: – Phenobarbital – Phenytoin – Carbamazepine – Oxcarbazepine Phenobarbital really pushes the liver into overdrive! This decimates hormones. Thus, phenobarbital may produce temporary infertility. The other medications push the liver less hard. But according to some studies, in some cases these epilepsy medications decrease fertility. In my own practice, I find this to be uncommon. These medications may also disturb child growth during pregnancy. This problem is called teratogenicity. It is described in another article (see below). Can a man with Epilepsy have a baby? Yes! Certainly and defintely and quite easily! A man with Epilepsy can have a baby. Many men with Epilepsy have babies every year. Just like women, there are a few extra things to keep track of. Does epilepsy or epilepsy medications affect fertility in men? As explained below, epilepsy medications can decrease sperm count. But because men produce so much sperm, usually epilepsy medications do not affect fertility in males. There are very few described cases of epilespy medications causing infertility in males. These cases are temporary. After changing medications, sexual function, sperm count and sperm function all improve. Does Epilepsy affect sperm count? Epilepsy may decrease sperm production. But this usually does not affect chances of pregnancy. Usually, men produce a lot of sperm. Every time a male ejaculates, he releases about 40 million or more sperm! Epilepsy may produce mild hormonal changes in men, like it does in women. This may reduce sperm production and may cause slightly higher abnormal sperms. But due to the huge number of sperm produced, the net effect is usually insignificant. Do epilepsy medications affect sperm count? Yes. This effect is more significant. Both kinds of medications described above can have this effect. (1) Valproate: It is unclear how valproate reduces male fertility. It may cause hormonal changes. It may also decrease energy production in the testes (mitochondrial dysfunction). Males treated with Valproate produce fewer sperm. They can get a low sperm count. They also produce higher numbers of abnormal sperm. Higher doses of Valproate are more likely to produce male infertility. The problem is less marked at lower doses. (2) “Enzyme inducing seizure medications” As listed before, these medications include: – Phenobarbital – Phenytoin – Carbamazepine – Oxcarbazepine As explained before, these medications put the liver into overdrive. In males, this causes the liver to decrease testosterone in the blood. This can lead to reduced and less speedy sperms. This effect is less dramatic than the effect of valproate. In my practice, decreased male fertility due to these medications is uncommon. Newer epilepsy medications are less likely to affect male fertility. For example: Levetiracetam is a newer seizure medication. It does not affect sex hormone levels and decreases sperm count only by 10-20%. So the chance that levetiracetam and newer epilepsy medications decrease fertility in males is very small. Can epilepsy medications cause impotence? Yes. Some epilepsy medications may decrease sexual hormones. This may decrease your sexual desire (libido). This is one obvious way in which epilepsy medications decrease fertility. Decreased sex certainly decreases the chances of

Fertility: Can a man or woman with epilepsy have a baby? Read More »

DBS surgery risks & Deep Brain Stimulation side effects, Side Effects of DBS For Essential Tremor – Drkharkar

DBS surgery risks & Deep Brain Stimulation side effects are relatively low. It is very easy to think only about the risks of the surgery itself. But the DBS surgery risk is relatively minor, and described below. A few weeks after the DBS surgery, the DBS electrical current is switched on. The current decreases Parkinson’s Disease symptoms. But sometimes, Deep Brain Stimulation side effects are seen. Stimulation can increase certain symptoms such as depression, thinking problems and rarely, falling. There is a small risk of DBS failure as well (10-15%). Although not a DBS risk as such, it is worthwhile to discuss it here. Let us learn more. Table Of Contents What are the DBS surgery risks (risk of the actual DBS surgery)? What is the risk of long-term Deep Brain Stimulation Side-effects? What is the risk of DBS failure? Dr. Siddharth Kharkar NeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson’s Clinic – Dr. Kharkar What are the DBS surgery risks (risk of the actual DBS surgery)? Although this is surgery on the brain, as compared to other surgeries, it is relatively minor. Therefore the DBS surgery risks are low. But they are not non-existent. The DBS surgery takes a few hours but is quite safe. Let us look at one of the largest studies on this topic, to know the DBS surgery risk. A group of German researchers studied 1,183 patients who had Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) surgery. This series included patients with Parkinson’s disease as well as with other diseases. These were their findings. The risk of death was less than 1%.  About 2% of patients had bleeding inside their head that caused weakness on one side of the body. In many patients, this weakness resolved by itself within 30 days. A few patients (0.6%) had uncommon problems such as infection. A few patients (0.6%) had somewhat unrelated problems such as pneumonia. In short: More than 95% of patients did not have any complications. The risk of death or permanent problems was minimal (about 1%). Overall, as previously mentioned DBS surgery risks are modest. They are on the lower side of those expected from a major surgery. Perhaps more important is to consider the long-term side effects of the electrical stimulation itself. [Click here for the entire study] What is the risk of long-term Deep Brain Stimulation Side-effects? A few weeks after the surgery is done, the DBS current (stimulation) is switched on. Most people have marked relief from their Parkinson’s symptoms at this time. Many people do not have any Deep Brain Stimulation side effects. But sometimes, the stimulation can cause some characteristic problems. A few weeks after surgery, the DBS device is switched on. This may cause worsening of some side effects. Deep Brain Stimulation side effects include possible worsening of 3 symptoms of Parkinson’s disease: It can worsen Depression, if you already have uncontrollable depression. It can worsen Thinking & Memory problems, especially if you already have them. It can worsen falling, if your falling is caused mostly due to instability. Depression and Memory: The first two problems usually happen only if you have these problems before DBS as well. This risks can be reduced by making sure you are a good DBS candidate. [Read “Am I a good DBS candidate?”] If you have uncontrolled deprssion or thinking/memory problems, these need to be controlled before you can have DBS. Also your doctor may recommend DBS of a different brain part called GPi. [Read about DBS targets]. A few weeks after surgery, the DBS device is switched on. This may cause worsening of some side effects. Instability and rarely, falling Let us think about two things that can cause you to fall if you have Parkinson’s: Imbalance – increases in 1/3rd of patients after DBS. Freezing – decrease in most patients after DBS. Overall, the beneficial effects outweigh the increased imbalance. So, usually patients fall less often after DBS.  But if the most important reason for you falling is that you are unstable, you should pause. And think. You should ask your doctor these 3 questions, BEFORE DBS. Why am I falling? Is it because of Freezing or Instability? Do I have a “Parkinson’s Plus Syndrome”? Is another problem (for example, B12 deficiency) causing my falls? If instability is the cause of your falls, proceed only after understanding the pros & cons. If you have a Parkinson’s plus syndrome, consider not getting DBS. If you are falling very often, you need to stop and think BEFORE you have DBS. In summary DBS improves most symptoms of Parkinson’s disease. But it may worsen three symptoms: 1. Falling: If you are falling because of instability. 2. Thinking/memory: If you already have these problems. 3. Depression: If you already have uncontrollable depression. No one is perfect. Most patients with Parkinson’s have these symptoms, in greater or lesser severity. This does not mean nobody can get DBS. But if you have very severe/uncontrollable problems with any of these three symptoms, you should discuss the pros/cons of DBS in detail with your doctor before proceeding. What is the risk of DBS failure? 10-15% Few patients do not get any benefit after DBS. Proper selection of the DBS candidate helps to reduce this risk. But, even if you don’t improve initially after DBS surgery, there is still hope. A initial DBS failure can be converted into a success. For example, the University of Florida & Harvard university studied patients who had not improved after DBS. This study included both Parkinson’s patients and some patients with other diseases. The most common reasons for failure were: Misdiagnosis. [read more] Incorrectly placed electrode. [read more] Incorrect DBS programming. (the DBS settings needed to be changed) Improper medication adjustment With optimized care such as changing medication doses and reprogramming the DBS, more than half these patients improved.  Therefore the DBS risk of failure can be lowered. You can click here for the entire study. In summary, DBS surgery risks are low. Deep Brain Stimulation side effects are uncommon, provided the evaluation is done carefully, BEFORE DBS. Ont the other hand, the chances of DBS success are very high. They are described in another article. Keywords – best

DBS surgery risks & Deep Brain Stimulation side effects, Side Effects of DBS For Essential Tremor – Drkharkar Read More »

What is the Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Parkinson’s? – Deep Brain Stimulation for Parkinson’s Disease – Drkharkar

Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Parkinson’s disease is excellent. According to Medtronic’s data, 85-90% of patients have significant improvement after DBS. DBS does not reduce all symptoms equally. It reduces some symptoms more than others. In most cases: DBS reduces the major symptoms of shaking, stiffness and slowness. Patients walk faster. However, DBS does not reduce imbalance. DBS reduces many non-motor symptoms of Parkinson’s disease. But it may worsen thinking problems & depression. So, we should discuss Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate under different headings. Please note that this is the average improvement after DBS. A few patients may not benefit. The reasons for DBS failure are also described below. Let us begin. Table Of Contents Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Shaking, slowness and stiffness Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Walking and imbalance Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Non-Motor symptoms Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Motor fluctuations Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Quality of life In how many patients does DBS fail completely? Bottom line: How many patients are happy they had DBS Dr. Siddharth Kharkar NeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson’s Clinic – Dr. Kharkar Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Shaking, slowness and stiffness Shaking (Tremor) responds very well to DBS. In most cases, the severity of tremor decreases by more than half (>50%). In the future, customized DBS may reduce tremor by almost 90%. Customized DBS includes putting the wire into other targets (such as the zona inserta). Currently, we can use this data during programming to stimulate these areas as well. DBS is very successful in reducing uncontrolled shaking (Tremor). Tremor is the most noticeable symptom of Parkinson’s. But, most patients complain that stiffness and slowness are most disabling. DBS works great in reducing these symptoms as well. Both are reduced by more than half (>50%). Again, future customized DBS may be even more successful. Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Walking and imbalance As expected, patients with Parkinson’s walk slowly. They may also have episodes when they feel “stuck” to the ground. This is called “Freezing”. After DBS, patients walk much faster. Also, “Freezing” is reduced. DBS enables patients to walk faster. Also, they get fewer episodes of feeling “stuck” to the ground (Freezing). What is the problem? DBS does not improve balance. In about 1/3rd of patients, it may worsen balance. So are falls more common after DBS? No. Most studies indicate that falls decrease after DBS. For example, Dr. Karachi reported that falls reduced in 1/3rd of patients after DBS. You see, one of the major cause of falls is “Freezing” of gait. Reduction in “freezing” leads to a reduction in falls. Again, this is an average. If you are falling due to instability rather than freezing, you may fall more often after DBS (see box). If I fall often, should I get DBS? You should discuss 3 questions with your doctor: 1. Why am I falling? Is it because of Freezing or Instability? 2. Do I have a Parkinson’s Plus Syndrome? 3. Is another problem (for example, B12 deficiency) causing my falls? If instability is the cause of your falls, proceed only after understanding the pros & cons. If you have a Parkinson’s Plus Syndrome, consider not getting DBS. If you are falling down often, you should find out the reason why you are falling BEFORE you get DBS surgery. Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Non-Motor symptoms Patients with Parkinson’s disease have non-movement problems as well. These include sleep problems, constipation, pain and many others. You can find articles on these problems on the site. Thankfully, DBS decreases many of these non-motor problems. For example, sleep improves after DBS. I, along with my colleagues at Kings college, published a research paper on improvement in sleep after DBS in 2018. DBS improves sleep and many other non-motor symptoms of Parkinson’s. The effect of DBS on some non-motor symptoms is unknown. For example, we don’t know if DBS reduces excessive sweating and urinary problems. Unfortunately, DBS may worsen a few non-motor symptoms. If you already have thinking/memory problems, DBS may worsen them. If you already have severe depression, DBS may worsen it. This possible worsening is important to consider. Please read these two articles to know more: [Good DBS surgical candidate] [DBS risks]. Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Motor fluctuations Before going on, let us look at the simple terms “OFF” and “ON”. OFF is how a Parkinson’s patient is without symptoms – he/she has very severe symptoms. ON is how a patient is when his treatment is working well – he has few symptoms. In late Parkinson’s disease, medications effect becomes inconsistent. This causes “Motor fluctuations”. In late Parkinson’s disease, your day may seem like a roller coaster ride. You are ON during some hours, and OFF during other hours. These ups and downs are called “Motor Fluctuations”. Let us look at the 2 most common motor fluctuations: Some patients report that their medications stop working after a few hours. They become “OFF”. This is called “Predictable wearing-OFF”. Some patients complain that their body shakes a lot after taking medications. This is called “Dyskinesia”. DBS reduces these fluctuations. On average, patients get 4-5 hours of extra ON-time after DBS. This is the major success of DBS. Also: Even when patients are OFF, their symptoms are less severe. Dyskinesias improve. On average, Dyskinesias are reduced by more than 80%. Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Quality of life The goal of reducing your symptoms is to improve your quality of life. So, the ultimate measure of Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate is an improvement in Quality of Life (QOL). The distinction is crucial. For example, if your slowness decreases by 60-70%, your doctor would be happy. But are you satisfied? Has that enabled you to have a better life? DBS helps you become independent in your ADLs (Activities of Daily Living such as bathing, dressing, eating, etc.). Does a high Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate enable you to have a better life? Yes. The evidence behind this is quite robust. In multiple studies, patients have reported

What is the Deep Brain Stimulation Success rate for Parkinson’s? – Deep Brain Stimulation for Parkinson’s Disease – Drkharkar Read More »

DBS procedure [5 steps including Levodopa Challenge Test & DBS surgery], Deep Brain Stimulation for Parkinson’s Disease – Drkhakar

The DBS procedure can appear daunting to a patient! There are 5 crucial steps: The 5 steps of a systematic DBS process 1. Pre-operative evaluation including Levodopa Challenge Test 2. Selection of DBS target and DBS device. 3. DBS surgery itself 4. Post-operative recovery Table Of Contents Pre-operative evaluation including Levodopa Challenge Test Selection of DBS target and DBS device DBS Surgery Post-Operative Recovery DBS Programming – switching it ON! How long does the improvement with Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) last? Dr. Siddharth Kharkar NeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson’s Clinic – Dr. Kharkar There are five formalities to complete before DBS surgery: There are five formalities to complete before DBS surgery: 1) Ruling out a Parkinson’s Mimic First and foremost, the diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease needs to be confirmed. The doctor will carefully talk to you and examine you. His/her main intention is to rule out a Parkinson’s Disease Mimic. A Parkinson’s Mimic is any disease that looks like Parkinson’s disease but is not. Parkinson’s Mimics include the Parkinson’s Plus syndromes. Your neurologist will look for these “Red-Flag” symptoms, which may indicate that you have a Parkinson’s Plus syndrome. Red flag: Your doctor will be extra careful if you have any of the following symptoms. ‘Red Flags’ suggesting that you may have a Parkinson’s Plus Syndrome 1. Lack of response to Levodopa. 2. Frequently falling, especially backwards. 3. Severe talking or swallowing problems. 4. Problems with eye movement. 5. Impotence. 6. Blurring of vision. 7. Blacking out when rising from a seated position. 8. Problems with thinking or memory loss. 9. Personality changes. 10. Symptoms only in the legs while the arms and hands are entirely normal. 11. Rapid progression of the disease. Click here to read more about Parkinson’s Mimics. Click here to read more about Parkinson’s Plus syndromes. A careful history and examination are critical. Also, a small therapeutic experiment is done. This experiment is the Levodopa Challenge Test. 2) Levodopa Challenge Test Most people with Parkinson’s Disease never stop responding to Levodopa. But the effect of Levodopa becomes shorter and shorter as the disease progresses, and sometimes it may cause side-effects. So, the reason for doing DBS is motor fluctuations, which are described here. Let us say a person who is going to have DBS takes a large quantity of Levodopa. This is called the “Levodopa Challenge Test”. What would you guess happens immediately afterwards? Here is the key: The person should improve, even at this stage. Significantly. A good Levodopa Challenge Test: Excellent improvement (>30%) after taking levodopa predicts that DBS will be successful. No one would expect this improvement to last the entire day – that is the reason that DBS is being done in the first place. But at least for an hour or so, the person should improve. Significantly. In fact, the maximal improvement that you get during the Levodopa Challenge Test is likely to be the maximal improvement after DBS. If a person fails to improve dramatically, then it predicts that DBS may not work. As with all things in life, this prediction is not absolute. How is the test done? You will be asked to stop taking your Parkinson’s medications after your night-time dose / at least for 12 hours. Most places will ask you to stop eating after dinner. You can keep drinking water as usual. You will be requested to come to the hospital in the early morning. There, the Neurologist will carefully examine you and give you a score for motor functioning. He/She will use a very lengthy scale called the UPDRS-scoring system. The UPDRS is a very complicated scoring system that measures your performance. Then, you will be given a sizeable dose of Levodopa, for example, 4 tablets. This dose is usually slightly higher than the dose you are currently taking. Many authorities recommend that 150% of your morning dose should be used. Doctors may use up to 200% of your morning dose if you fail the test once. The Neurologist will again reexamine you 30 minutes, 1 hour and if needed 1.5 hours after taking the Levodopa tablets. What is “Significant Improvement”? This measurement cannot be subjective. What may seem significant to your doctor may not seem significant to you. To avoid such ambiguity, we use the UPDRS to quantify your symptoms. The minimum improvement required to predict a good DBS response is known. If at any point after taking the challenge dose, your UPDRS score improves by 30% or more, then you are likely to improve after DBS. This is a single page of the UPDRS scoring sheet. You can access the complete scoring sheet by clicking on the picture. If I fail the Levodopa Challenge Test, can I still get DBS? Some people can. If you do not improve, the reason for non-improvement should be found. If you failed the Levodopa Challenge Test because of specific reasons, you could still have DBS. Reason for Levodopa Challenge Test Failure Resolution The dose of Levodopa used was not large enough May need to re-do test with a larger dose. You cannot tolerate a large dose – you get too nauseous. May need to take tablets for nausea so that a large enough dose can be given. You start shaking too much after a large dose (these are called dyskinesias). So, your post-challenge scores are low. May need to proceed with DBS without the assurance provided by the Levodopa Challenge Test. Your gut did not absorb the Levodopa. For example, you ate a heavy breakfast by mistake or were constipated. May need to repeat the test with proper precautions. You failed the test because your Tremor did not improve after the Levodopa dose. May proceed, but discuss with your doctor adequately. Tremor may respond to DBS even if it does not improve with the levodopa challenge. You failed the test because the stiffness of your body, walking or unsteadiness did not improve after the levodopa challenge. Be very careful. These symptoms may not improve after DBS either. You have a Parkinson’s Mimic, possibly a Parkinson’s Plus Syndrome. DBS is not a good option, at present. But you may want to

DBS procedure [5 steps including Levodopa Challenge Test & DBS surgery], Deep Brain Stimulation for Parkinson’s Disease – Drkhakar Read More »

Best DBS Device for Parkinson’s in India

Which is the best DBS device? Actually, no DBS device has been proven to the best. All DBS devices are very good. Newer devices provide many additional features. But whether these additional features help patients in the real world is not known. Let us learn about these issues. Table Of Contents Which companies manufacture Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) systems? Is Abbott’s “Infinity” the best DBS device? How can “steering” current help? Is Boston Scientific’s “Vercise” the best DBS device? Are the more expensive Infinity / Vercise DBS devices really better than the older, cheaper Activa DBS device? Which is the best device for DBS? How many years does the battery of Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) last? Dr. Siddharth Kharkar NeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson’s Clinic – Dr. Kharkar Which companies manufacture Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) systems? Earlier, only Medtronic made a Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) system. Their device is called “Activa”. The Medtronic-Activa system has 3 varieties. PC – non-rechargeable. RC-Rechargeable & SC – single channel for one-sided stimulation only. Subsequently, two more devices were approved: Abbott – The device is called “Infinity”. Boston Scientific – The device is called “Vercise”. Is Abbott’s “Infinity” the best DBS device? There are 2 varieties of the system. The Abbott system has 2 varieties. The larger one (Infinity-7) is for the usual stimulation (both sides of the brain). The smaller one (Infinity-5) can only do one-sided stimulation. There are 2 additional advantages:Small size: The single-channel device (Infinity-5) is the smallest DBS battery available. But, that is not the most crucial feature of the Infinity system.More stimulation points: In the Infinity system, you can select a wire with more stimulation points at the end (up to 8). So, you can give stimulation precisely – to only a small brain part.Current steering: The Infinity DBS system can “steer” the electrical current. It can point the electrical current in a particular direction. So if you want only the right side of the wire to get current, you can do that. Current to the left – you got it! Here is a video of how this is done. This video mentions the Vercise device (described below), which has similar features: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nVLWauTKfPo How can “steering” current help? This ability is useful when the end of the wire is not exactly in the target. For example, let us say the target is slightly to the left of the wire. Then, the Infinity device can make the current go more to the left. It may also help to reduce side-effects. For example, let us say stimulation is causing hoarseness of voice. The Infinity system can steer current away from the part whose stimulation is causing hoarseness. So, in theory, this ability should improve movement while at the same time reducing side-effects. Is Boston Scientific’s “Vercise” the best DBS device? There are 2 varieties of the system. Abbot’s Vercise System – The Gevia is rechargeable. The PC model is not rechargeable. There are 4 advantages:Longevity: There are two varieties of the Vercise system – rechargeable and non-rechargeable. The rechargeable Vercise system holds a trump card. You don’t need to replace the battery for a long time! (see below) Vercise-Gevia is the energizer bunny of DBS-systems. It also has all the other technical features of other systems. More stimulation points: Same as the Infinity system.Current steering: Earlier, the Vercise system was not capable of “steering” current. In 2019, a newer version of the device (specifically, a newer wire called Cartesia) was approved. This more recent version is capable of steering current. Are the more expensive Infinity / Vercise DBS devices really better than the older, cheaper Activa DBS device? No one has done a head-to-head study comparing these devices. Therefore, we don’t know if one of these devices is better than all others – the “best DBS device”. My take on it is this: FOR GPi-DBS: Medtronic-Activia is the only approved choice. As noted before, at present, the Infinity & Vercise systems are not approved for GPi-DBS. For STN DBS: Both the newer devices are, in general, more expensive than the Medtronic device. The crucial technical difference is “Current Steering”. The other variables: size & longevity, are usually less important. ” IF the neurosurgeon places the end of the wire perfectly inside the STN, THEN the effect of all devices should be similar. “ Putting the wire perfectly into the STN is not easy. As noted in a previous article, they are like two little peas in the centre of the head. Neurosurgeons do a phenomenal, near-superhuman task by doing it perfectly most of the time. But sometimes, the lead may be a few millimetres off-target. Neurosurgeons hit the STN with near-superhuman skill. But they are not infallible. Using the Vercise/Infinity devices is planning for a contingency, which rarely arises. If you are monetarily able to do so, you could arrange for this rare contingency. Which is the best device for DBS? Both the newer devices are, in general, more expensive than the Medtronic device. The newer devices are attractive in principle. But, they have not been proven to be more effective than the Medtronic device. For GPi-DBS, the only choice is Medtronic-Activa system. For STN-DBS, any of these devices is an excellent choice. For STN-DBS, the doctor usually chooses the device he/she is most comfortable with. Sometimes, choosing is difficult because the differences are minor. Reference / Further reading: Here is an excellent article about DBS device selection: Okun et al. 2019 – Tips for choosing a DBS device – JAMA Neurology Here is a phenomenal, but very technical, article comparing all DBS devices: Paff et al. 2020 – Update on current technologies for DBS in Parkinson’s disease – Journal of Movement Disorders. How many years does the battery of Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) last? The best DBS device would have a never-ending battery. But, in real-life the DBS battery does run out after some years. Each of these devices has two varieties: Non-rechargeable & Rechargeable. The non-rechargeable batteries are cheaper. However, they last for a

Best DBS Device for Parkinson’s in India Read More »

STN-DBS versus GPi-DBS – Which DBS location is best?

STN-DBS versus GPI-DBS – Which DBS location is better? Worldwide, the most common DBS location is a brain part called the Subthalamic Nucleus (STN-DBS). So, most doctors think it is better. But in some patients, an alternative location may be better. This alternative location is the Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi). In fact, some doctors think that GPi-DBS is better in all cases! Your doctor will do this thinking for you. He/She will tell you the proposed location. But, its good to know how he/she thinks! Let us learn quickly about the pros & cons of these locations. Table Of Contents What do you mean by DBS-Location? Subthalamic Nucleus (STN-DBS) Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi-DBS) STN-DBS versus GPi-DBS Dr. Siddharth Kharkar NeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson’s Clinic – Dr. Kharkar What do you mean by DBS-Location? DBS passes a small electrical current into a small brain part. The small brain part is called the DBS location. Many doctors will call it the DBS Target instead. Look at the picture below. The end of the DBS wire marks the location. The DBS location will get a small current from the Battery. Usually, there are two wires, one on the left and one on the right. See the wire going into the brain? The location where it ends is the location that will get the current. That is the “DBS location” (or “DBS Target”) You could use any location in the brain. But doctors have found two great locations already. The names of these two locations are: Subthalamic Nucleus (STN) Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi) Subthalamic Nucleus (STN-DBS) Where is the Subthalamic Nucleus (STN)? The STN is deep, very deep, inside the brain. There is one two STNs. One on the left, and one on the right. They are also tiny. Like peas. Ok, so close your eyes, and imagine. Two peas, almost touching each other, in the centre of your head, just below your ears. The 2 STNs are like two small peas, in the center of the head. That’s it! That is where the two STNs are. What is the benefit of STN-DBS? Let us say your doctor puts the end of the wire into the STN. And switches on the small current. What happens? STN-DBS decreases the symptoms of Parkinson’s disease. You need less levodopa after STN-DBS. Usually, the levodopa dose can be gradually reduced by 1/2. STN-DBS also keeps acting throughout the day, so it decreases “Predictable-OFFs”. A simple example: Let us talk about an imaginary person – Mr. Salisbury. Mr. Salisbury is already taking 12 tablets of levodopa. He takes 3 tablets every 4 hours. A few minutes after he takes this high dose, he gets nauseous and sometimes starts shaking too much. But he insists “But I absolutely need this dose to function!” Mr. Salisbury needs a high dose of levodopa to function. But every dose makes him shake a lot. And every dose only works for 2 hours. “I know these are Dyskinesias” he says. “But I put up with them because I need that high dose of levodopa to function!“. That is not all. Just 2 hours after taking the levodopa, it’s effect wears off. Mr. Salisbury goes into the OFF-state again. He almost completely freezes. This wearing-Off is very predictable. After STN-DBS, Mr. Salisbury becomes ON with only 1.5 tablets of Levodopa. Not only that, the effect now lasts for 4 hours. Even when he goes into the OFF-state, he is not completely OFF. He does not completely freeze. Mr. Salisbury is particularly happy that his levodopa dose has decreased. Because his dose has decreased, he has less severe dyskinesias. After STN-DBS, you may need only 50% of your current levodopa dose. In summary: STN-DBS decreases both Predictable-OFF & Dyskinesias. But, the effect on dyskinesias is indirect. What are the side-effects of STN-DBS? STN-DBS causes two characteristic side-effects. Increasing severe depression, if you already have it. Increasing memory problems, if you already have them. If you are dramatically depressed or have severe memory problems, perhaps STN would not be the right DBS location for you. STN-DBS may rarely cause depression or memory problems. But this is rare. Mostly, all it does is to increase severe problems, if you already have them. So, if you already have these very severe problems, STN-DBS may not be the right choice. What can you choose instead of the usual STN-DBS? If you have these problems, and they are severe, you should probably not choose usual DBS. You can choose: Not to have DBS or STN-DBS of only one side or DBS of another target called the Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi) If depression or memory problems are extremely dramatic, then not having DBS may be considered. For borderline problems, many doctors consider another target – the GPi. This is called GPi-DBS. Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi-DBS) Where is the Globus Pallidus Interna (GPi)? The GPi is not as deeply located as the STN. There are two GPis. One on the left, and one on the right. The GPis are bigger. They are shaped like this yo-yo here. Imagine a small yo-yo like this, inside your head, just above your ears. The two GPi look somewhat like a Yo-Yo. They are larger than the STN. That’s it! That’s where the two GPi are. What is the benefit of GPi-DBS? Overall, GPi-DBS causes the same benefits as STN-DBS. But, the way it does so is different. GPi-DBS decreases the side-effects of levodopa, especially DYSKINESIA. Let’s consider an imaginary person, Ms. Mary. Ms. Mary is not able to take enough levodopa to decrease his symptoms. She can only take 4 tablets in a day. Why? Because when she takes more tablets, the body starts shaking too much. Like the video below, posted by a brave patient on youtube. These movements are called “Dyskinesia”. “I really wish I could take more medication!” says Mary. “But if I try to increase it, this dyskinesia just becomes intolerable!” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AaOWRYqMQc0 Wouldn’t it be wonderful if these bad movements went away? GPi-DBS does that.

STN-DBS versus GPi-DBS – Which DBS location is best? Read More »

Who is a good candidate for Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS)?

Allow me to give you the Patient Criteria for a good DBS candidate upfront. You are the ideal DBS candidate if you fulfil all the following: Go Ahead with DBS Stop & re-consider 1. Your life is significantly hampered, despite taking proper medications 2. If the diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease is sure, and there are no “red flags.” 3. You improve markedly with the “Levodopa Challenge test”. 4. You clearly understand the risks & success rates, and have realistic expectations 1. If you have other serious medical problems which would make surgery risky. 2. If you are uncontrollably depressed. 3. If you have severe thinking & memory problems. Please try to understand this table entirely before you get DBS surgery done. I will try to explain it to you, in the simplest possible terms. Let us start. Table Of Contents Who is a good DBS candidate? What is the reason you want to consider DBS? There is a good reason. What next? How can doctors predict if you will improve after DBS? How are other diagnoses ruled out? How can doctors predict long term side-effects from DBS surgery? Please summarize. Who is the ideal candidate for DBS? How do doctors verify these patient criteria? Do I need to fulfil all patient criteria to get DBS? Dr. Siddharth Kharkar NeuroPlus Epilepsy & Parkinson’s Clinic – Dr. Kharkar Who is a good DBS candidate? Please note that here, we will talk only about DBS for Parkinson’s. DBS is used for other problems as well – including epilepsy. We will not talk about those conditions in this article. DBS can result in good improvement in some Parkinson’s Patients. Videos such as the one below are genuine and very encouraging. This video has been posted on Youtube by the Neuromedical Center in the USA. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wZZ4Vf3HinA All patients may not get the same benefit. So, proper selection of: The patient The location of stimulation The device with which stimulation is done is very important. Here we will talk about patient selection. The other topics are covered later. Here is the first question to answer: What is the reason you want to consider DBS? There is only one reason to consider DBS. You should consider DBS if – despite taking medications – your life is hampered by Parkinson’s Disease. We call this “Disability”. You know, even late-stage Parkinson’s patients improve after a single big dose of Levodopa! So why are patient’s activities hampered? They are hampered because of motor fluctuations. Let us look at the 2 most common fluctuations: 1. Predictable Wearing-OFF: You might feel almost perfect after taking Levodopa. But the effect wears-off too soon. It may wear off after 2 hours, or sometimes even after 1 hour. You can literally predict what is going to happen. Then you take another dose, and you’re fine. But then within 1-2 hours, the same thing happens again! Here is a video posted by Orion Pharma. A patient called Ms. Doreen describes her wearing-off symptoms: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5EjbX-x51r0 This “Wearing-Off” problem is probably the most common reason for DBS surgeries. 2. Dose-Limiting Dyskinesias: Initially, you took small doses of Levodopa. As the years went by, you needed larger doses. Fine. You still improved But some people notice that when they take larger doses, their body starts shaking. For lack of a better description – these excessive movements look like slow break-dancing. These are called “dyskinesias”. They can be quite severe. Here is a video of Dyskinesias caused by Levodopa. This video has been posted by a brave patient named Ms. Tessie on youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AaOWRYqMQc0 So, some people are in a quandary. Don’t take enough Levodopa, and they become stiff. Take enough Levodopa, and get dyskinesias. These patients cannot take as much Levodopa as they need because of severe “dyskinesias”. The way out is DBS. STN-DBS makes you function even with a 50% levodopa dose. GPi-DBS is excellent in another way: You can read more here [STN versus GPi DBS]. There is a good reason. What next? There are two essential goals of DBS surgery for Parkinson’s Disease: To improve the patient’s functioning. To avoid side-effects Let us look at each one of these: How can doctors predict if you will improve after DBS? At present, we are not able to use DBS for Parkinson’s Plus Syndromes. PSP & other Parkinson’s plus syndromes do not improve after regular DBS. So, a patient with a “Parkinson’s Plus Syndrome” is not a good candidate for DBS. At least, at present. In the future, a modified DBS procedure may be useful in Parkinson’s Plus Syndromes. But at present, a major task before DBS is to confirm Parkinson’s disease and rule out other conditions. If you really have Parkinson’s disease (and not a Parkinson’s Mimic), then there is an excellent chance of improvement after DBS. How are other diagnoses ruled out? Parkinson’s Plus Syndromes are diagnosed by talking and examining you. Doctors call this a “clinical diagnosis”. The presence of some symptoms may warn you that you have a “Parkinson’s Plus Syndrome”. Doctors call these symptoms “Red Flags”. Here is a list of such red flags: Red flags – you may have a “Parkinson’s Plus” syndrome instead Lack of response to Levodopa. Frequently falling down, especially backwards. Severe talking or swallowing problems. Problems with eye movement. Impotence. Blurring of vision. Blacking out when rising from a seated position. Problems with thinking or memory loss. Personality changes. Symptoms only in the legs while the arms and hands are entirely normal. Rapid progression of the disease. When in doubt, blood tests, MRI or FDOPA scan may help to rule out other conditions. You can read more here [Conditions that look like Parkinson’s]. Levodopa Challenge Test: Let’s say your doctor is sure that you have Parkinson’s disease. What else does he/she do to predict DBS response accurately? He/She give you a single big dose of Levodopa. This is called a “Levodopa Challenge”. Doctors have discovered that the improvement after a large dose of Levodopa predicts improvement after DBS. If you

Who is a good candidate for Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS)? Read More »